My rough collie loves it!
I have a rotator cuff tear, which often makes it painful to throw overhead. I find I get great distance with an underhand throw using the rope attached. My rough collie loves it! He will retrieve the toy using either the ball or the rope, and will shake it around. Tug is equally fun! He has no interest in chewing it so I cannot attest to its durability in that regard. For the price, this toy is definitely a win!